FE420 Bye, Bye Cookie: Hello Delayed Reinforcement!

Do you struggle to get your dog's attention without a cookie (or toy!) in your hand? Are you tired of your dog only responding to a cue until you reach into your pocket?

Course Details

Do you struggle to get your dog's attention without a cookie (or toy!) in your hand? Are you tired of your dog only responding to a cue until you reach into your pocket?

Maybe at trials you're holding onto a few pieces of food after you set the treats down, just so you can shove that last piece of food into their mouth right before you step foot in the ring!

You’re frustrated! You feel like you’ve put a lot of time and effort into training the skills your dog needs to be successful, but training still feels very transactional and you're struggling to make it into the ring and keep your dog's focus when the food is gone.

Or perhaps you've dreamed of being able to pre-place the reward on the ground in your training without your dog running straight to it. Imagine being able to set their toy (or food bowl!) at the end of the weaves to reward their independent send!

You’ve seen other students whose dogs seem to choose work over self-rewarding. It looks so easy! Maybe you’ve even thought, “my dog could never do that.”

But with a little help, you can get there… because it’s not magic— it’s training.

In this class, we will help your dog develop the ability to work and focus even when there is no reward on your body. We will build up your dog's ability to work no matter where the reward is located and without any type of lid to prevent stealing!

We want our dogs to willingly leave the reward and confidently know they will get it later! The goal is an eager dog with a clear head.

Throughout the class, we will cover a variety of topics, including

  • Choosing to ignore distractions

  • Developing a marker cue for rewards off our body (food and/or toys!)

  • Leaving the reward to work at a distance
  • Introduction to increasing the duration of work between rewards

  • Keeping focus and staying on task even when the work takes you near the reward location. (Heeling, recalls, "sends" in agility and obedience...)

Dogs of any age and experience level are welcome, although I recommend they are at least 6 months old. Whether you're looking to build a stronger bond with your dog or improve their performance in obedience or agility, this class is designed to help you achieve your goals.

If you want to teach your dog to work without rewards on your body, this is the class for you! Mark your calendar — registration opens on the 22nd!

Here is a compilation video of some students from the October 2019 class!:

Teaching Approach

Lectures are released at the start of each week with more lectures than most students will be expected to complete within the 6 weeks of class. Students new to this topic will primarily be working on lectures from the first 3 weeks of class.

The lectures are broken down by each skill. I have written objectives and then written instructions for each step followed by multiple video examples for each step. The videos are usually between 30sec to 2min long and are taken from training sessions of a variety of dogs and breeds. I do not use voiceover or subtitles in the video. At the end of each lecture is a homework summary with the steps quickly summarized in order.

The handler will need to bend down to the floor to pick up a food bowl multiple times in a session for many of the skills. A food robot can be used in the place of a food bowl if that is physically easier for the handler. Toys may be substituted for the food bowl if the dog can give up the toy without conflict.

This class will have a Teacher's Assistant (TA) available in the Facebook study group to help the Bronze and Silver students! Directions for joining that Facebook group will be in the classroom after you register.

Syllabus

Exact release schedule will be determined by the gold students but roughly follows this setup. The majority of the lectures will be released in weeks 1-3 for more experienced dogs to move slightly faster. Dogs new to the concept of rewards at a distance will likely spend the full session on the lectures in the first 3 weeks of class.

Week 1:

  • Beginning uncued/automatic leave its
  • Teaching different reward marker cues
  • Leaving the reward to get the reward (beginning sends)
  • Training with food off our body- starting zen bowl cues
  • Dealing with failures
  • Using toys as a reward
  • Discriminating between reward markers

Week 2:

  • Building motivation for the zen bowl
  • Adding work before the reward off our body
  • Sends away from Zen Bowls
  • Beginning attention walking
  • Moving by distractions
  • Mixing up reward cues during work
  • Room service delivery with rewards at a distance

Week 3:

  • Building distance from the reward location
  • Think harder! Sending the dog out near the reward location
  • Sequencing multiple behaviors before rewarding
  • Leaving people with food

Week 4:

  • Sequencing behaviors with the reward at a distance
  • Will you feed me? Leaving the reward with a helper
  • Leaving the reward past a threshold/ ring gate/ out of sight
  • Recall away from reward
  • Moving towards the reward

Week 5:

  • Moving towards the reward in movement-based behaviors (agility, recalls)
  • Duration of work: multiple setups and transitions (obedience)
  • Setups wtih zen bowl pressure
  • Distractions with the Zen Bowl as reward

Week 6:

  • Using reward placements in training
  • How to set up training sessions
  • Surprise distractions

Prerequisites & Supplies

There are no prerequisites for this class! This is a foundation class appropriate for even young (6+ months) dogs. Young dogs without many established behaviors can set a great foundation for choosing to work with rewards at a distance, but will spend more time on choosing to leave the reward vs the duration of work without a reward.

To work on all exercises, teams should have the start of a "send" to a mat or target from 5 feet away, at least 3 solid behaviors on just a verbal cue, and good focus with minor distractions. The majority of teams will NOT make it through all the lectures in just 6 weeks.

Advanced teams who are already trialing should still expect to go back to the foundation exercises presented in the class.

Most exercises can be done in a small space such as a living room. For advanced versions of exercises, teams may benefit from having enough space to set up a jump (for agility students), and/or a ring entrance (for all sports). Advanced students may progress to doing small agility sequences or heeling the last 2 weeks of class.

Equipment needed:

- rewards! Toys can be used for most exercises if the team prefers it to food and the dog already has a basic understanding of how to bring it back to the handler and willingly release it.

- a target the dog knows how to send to such as a mat, crate, or platform (if the dog does not yet know a send away, a lecture will introduce how to teach this topic).

- zen bowl (a reward container the dog can eat out of such as a special food bowl or Tupperware container.

Optional: a helper. Having another person play the role as a distractor will be used in 2 of the lectures. Working teams can skip the exercise if they don't have access to a helper.

- Optional: A jump, tunnel, or cone

Sample Lecture

4-1A: Sequencing with Rewards at a Distance (Flow)

Goal of the Exercise

This exercise combines two of the topics we've been discussing in this class:

  1. Not rewarding every behavior and
  2. Getting rewards off our body.

Really this is just the week 3 lecture on "more work" but using the reward at a distance skills instead of in your pocket!

For this lecture, we are going to work on only well-known behaviors. Behaviors that if you cue it, you know the dog can do it and can do it well. At that point, they don't NEED a reward for every rep. These are well known behaviors after all. But we also can't just go cold turkey and never reward it again. We need to gradually extend work and teach the dog that they can do it without the reward on our body.

This lecture will continue to look at the concepts of flow introduced in lecture 3-3B. The next lecture will look at more formality with pauses and distinct exercises for an obedience focus. I start with this flow lecture first as it's typically easier for most dogs!

There is a specific section on agility in this lecture as agility is all about flow!

Prerequisite:

Before starting this lecture your dog should be leaving the reward you set down and going with you fairly easily as you move away from the reward. (lecture 3-1)

And should have some exposure to doing more than one behavior before getting a reward. (lecture 3-3A and 3-3B flow section.)

Flow Sessions with Rewards at a Distance (Obedience)

Keep working on having your dog watch you set their reward down and then move slightly away from it in order to do some simple work.

Your goal will be to increase the number of behaviors before the reward and gently push at their boundary. Watch closely for signs of frustration and make sure to reward the hard vs easy reps differently too! Easy might just mean a send to the dish. While hard might mean a dish send + 3 cookie tosses! Or maybe easy = kibble, and hard= cheese!

Remember to mix in plenty of easy reps along with your harder ones! Aim for at least a 2:1 ratio of two easy reps for every hard one!

Over time, what sequences/behaviors qualify as "hard" should start to change. Just because X+Y+Z felt hard one week, that doesn't mean it's going to be hard this week. Make sure to evaluate on a regular basis what actually feels difficult vs what is just a habit to reward.

Try to focus on flowing smoothly from one exercise to another without a lot of pauses. Think of using cone sends, heeling, going through your legs, etc to keep your dog moving and not having as many obvious places where the dog starts to think about the lack of cookie.

Most of your work at this point should be moving AWAY from the reward, and giving the cue to the dish when your back is still to it! You don't want your turn towards the dish to be the cue to go to the dish or you're digging a hole for future weeks!

I love this video with Jo working on a few cues before the reward. The jump easily gets Jo moving away from the dish and flows well to the stationary work at the end.

Here Marina is working on adding some excitement with running from the dish with mom and working. The first rep show is going over a jump and a cone, and then she moves on to some heeling and a cone send! She keeps it very fast paced and very little duration of work while still accomplishing the goal of adding in more work!

Agility

In agility, keep working on mixing up how many obstacles you're doing. Most of your work at this point should be moving AWAY from the reward, and giving the cue to the dish when your back is still to it! Don't make the mistake of always moving towards the reward as you're cuing it or the dog will start anticipating that motion towards the reward= go!

Working with the toy on the ground was (still working on!) a really difficult choice for Ginny even with a solid foundation of doing it in obedience for her zen bowl and the toy. These are 2 short sessions working on this skill. She's slow and thinking lots!!! The height of the jump isn't the primary issue, but I still choose to lower it to make it easier for her to choose to the jump when her brain hurts.

And this video with Ginny is after several weeks of work on this skill. I show a few longer sequences before cuing her toy reward, mixed up with some shorter 3 obstacle reps. This is after quite a bit of work on running with her toy at a distance, it's ok if you're not ready for this much work! Note that in the 2nd clip and very last clip she has to do a turn somewhat near the reward. Skip that if your dog isn't ready! We will discuss that more in a later lecture.

Homework Recap:

1. Review the step of putting the reward down and moving away from the reward. Get eye contact, cue the reward.

2. Work on moving away from the reward, cuing a simple behavior, then cuing the reward. Make sure the reward cue is primarily given when the dog's back is to the reward! Cue the dish, THEN turn towards it.

3. Mix up the number of cues you ask for before cuing the reward. Mix up a minimum of two easy reps for every hard rep!! Remember that "flow" can make it easier.

  • Reward differently on easy vs hard reps!


Instructors

Laura Waudby (she/they) trains and competes in obedience, rally, and agility. She was halfway to her OTCH with her UDX corgi, Lance, before his uexpected early retirement. She also has championship titles in USDAA and UKI. By day...

Read more

Registration

Choose the plan that fits your goals and start learning at your own pace.

Gold

$260

Enrollment limit: 12

  • Access to all lectures and homework forums discussion
  • Read all posted questions and answers
  • Watch all posted videos
  • Post general questions to discussion forum
  • Submit written assignments
  • Post dog specific questions
  • Post videos (unlimited)
  • Receive instructor feedback

Registration dates:

November 22, 2025 - December 15, 2025

Silver

$130

Enrollment limit: 25

  • Access to all lectures and homework forums discussion
  • Read all posted questions and answers
  • Watch all posted videos
  • Post general questions to discussion forum
  • Post dog specific questions (video only)
  • Post videos (up to 2)
  • Receive instructor feedback

Registration dates:

November 22, 2025 - December 15, 2025

Bronze

$65

Enrollment limit: Unlimited

  • Access to all lectures and homework forums discussion
  • Read all posted questions and answers
  • Watch all posted videos

Registration dates:

November 22, 2025 - December 15, 2025

Scholarship available! Apply here

Why choose us?

We offer a variety of online training solutions designed to help you and your furry friend achieve success

Certified trainers

Learn from professionals with years of experience in canine behavior

Read more

Proven methods

Science-backed positive reinforcement techniques that actually work

Read more

Personalized approach

Programs tailored to your dog’s unique needs and personality

Read more

Engaging lessons

Keep training exciting with interactive exercises and games

Read more

FAQ

Explore the questions we get asked most often and find out everything you need for a smooth experience with us.

Our testimonials

Don't just take our word for it — see what our clients say about their experience working with us.

I am continually amazed at how much I learn with each class. Watching both the teacher's video's and the student's videos gives me lots of opportunity to think through the elements and break it down for myself and my dog.

Read all testimonials

I have struggled to find a trainer in my area that would consistently work with my reactive dog. We often got dumped in the summer, classes cancelled, or was told that we weren't part of the trainers focus. I thought that I would never be able to improve my training beyond reading and watching DVDs. I thought that I would never get personal feedback. I felt discouraged and excluded from the dog training community. I thought that I would always have mediocre training and a mediocre relationship with my dog. A friend recommended FDSA and I enrolled in "It's All Tricks" with Deborah Jones at Gold level. In 6 weeks my dog has become more confident than I've ever seen her. She is more motivated and eager to learn. Furthermore, my confidence as a trainer has improved. I finally feel like I have a resource that I can rely on. At FDSA it doesn't matter that my dog is reactive, we can finally work on exercises that would have been completely inaccessible before. Deb has been absolutely wonderful to work with. She provides kind, encouraging and constructive feedback with meaningful critique. This experience has been the epitome of what I have always dreamt that training my dog would be. I cannot be thankful enough to have discovered FDSA. It has given my dog and I a second chance at having a successful, meaningful relationship. I cannot wait to enroll in more classes. I wasn't so certain that online classes would be REALLY useful - I am blown away by how much one can learn and implement through the online system - certainly makes it possible to participate in novel learning experiences that would not otherwise be available!

Read all testimonials

I live in a remote area several hours away from experienced positive competitive obedience dog trainers, so Fenzi Academy gives me a great opportunity to get instruction from some of the best positive reinforcement trainers in the country. My current dog is getting a much better foundation than my previous dogs due to having access to this great instruction. Thank you! It is amazing to realize that Internet training isn't "second best". The success of training through video and critiques and lectures is nothing short of amazing. Thank you for bringing this quality of instruction to everyone, regardless of their geographical location The class was thoughtfully planned with just enough material each week to keep us busy but not overwhelmed. The lectures and videos were clear and easy to follow. Can't wait for the next class!

Read all testimonials